Main Index

Printing 101
Mr. Toad's Templates
Disc Design Strategies
Disc Design Critiques

Elvis Costello
Los Lobos
Ani DiFranco
Winter's Solstice
Flaco Jimenez
Shawn Colvin
Vaughan Williams

Ink Not Light
Proof Early, Proof Often
Formatting and Layout
For The Novice
File Management
Miscellaneous
Further Study
About This Site

Disc Design Critique

Vaughan Williams:

"Symphony #5"

Haitink/LPO (EMI Classics)

This is an unusual disc. It has only a single flaw, a flaw that you almost never see on disc designs for classical recordings. There's text in the mirror band.
Notice how Bernard Haitink's last name crosses the mirror band. The uneven background causes a distracting interference, making the type less legible, as the silver color varies according to what angle you hold the disc at - on the scanner, it appears quite dark. It would have been better to rearrange the type so that it was limited only to the continuous silver area outside the mirror band.

Classical music disc designs are almost always clear, conservative, and label-specific.  For example, all Deutsche Grammophon discs follow the same design formula; only the text changes.  They get it right once, and that's enough. 

4 D.G. discs
None of my other EMI discs look like this Vaughan Williams example, though. Strange...
Previous: Shawn Colvin Next: Designing for Ink, Not Light

Copyright © 2000 Marvin Humphrey

All rights reserved.